Social Media Don’t Sell. Get Over It!

Social Media Don’t Sell. Get Over It!

social media marketing world event in San DiegoDuring Social Media Marketing World event in San Diego last month, Chris Brogan gave a provocative session, aptly called: You Aren’t Going to Like This: Social Media Isn’t the Answer! It echoed what I strongly believe and what I tend to recommend during my consulting with clients in the travel and hospitality industry. In essence, social media are an important part of the digital channels an organization needs to embrace, but they are mere “outposts” in your communication mix, part of a bigger, four-step approach which can be summarized as follows:

HOME BASE

Home base is perhaps the most important place to focus and invest in, yet, many of us tend to stray away towards the shiny new toys, in particular within the social media universe (Vine, anyone?). In other words, ensure you have the basics right before moving on to social media, or said otherwise: make sure you excel at 1.0 before you focus on web 2.0!

Thus, how recent and optimized is your web site? Is it transactional? Mobile optimized? Have you measured conversation rates, or other aspect of the sales funnel recently? Having a landing page that shows social proof, for example seeing friends who “like” the page, give a more human side to corporate sites.

Master The Digital Channel - Owner's Compass

MEDIA EMPIRE

As we have entered an era where content marketing is the new advertising, brands now need to think and act as publishers. Coca Cola or Red Bull are two companies often referred to as great examples of brands who do this well, managing their owned media to cater to wider audiences, thus reducing their reliance to more traditional, paid media. Being a media empire means going beyond the web site to churn quality content on your own blog, using videos or photos to convey your message, publish ebooks, produce a podcast or get speaking engagements. But perhaps the most important element is the one many of us tend to dismiss as an antiquated tactic: email.

As Chris made clear, brands need to work on their home base and above all, strive to build a strong email list in order to foster quality relationship marketing tactics. So much so, in fact, that Chris made this startling revelation: he gets 10 times more revenues from his email list than from all his social media activities combined. Impressive, considering he admitted to having an email list of maybe 20,000 names, while he’s known to have fans and followers in the hundreds of thousands!

OUTPOSTS

Master the digital channels - Outposts

Source: Chris Brogan presentation at #SMMW13

Social platforms are an important part of the digital channels communications, as we can now choose through numerous established ones: Facebook, Linkedin, Twitter, not to mention industry-specific outposts such as TripAdvisor. Then we have up-and-coming ones, such as “Pinstagram” as Brogan dubbed the photo-sharing darlings Pinterest and Instagram, Google+, not to mention digital native applications like Foursquare, for example. But do we use these outpost to “sell”? More often than not, the answer is negative. In most cases, brands strive (or should) to bring online users to their home base, either through their media empire or communication outposts outlined above.

This echoes the finding from the TEXT100 research conducted in November 2012, illustrating how social media plays a key role in the travel decision influence process across the globe, as well as during the travel experience period, but not necessarily at the booking stage. So, to answer the question raised in the title of this post: social media doesn’t sell, if you strictly consider the booking aspect and direct conversion rates on your site. But that’s not to say it does not have a considerable impact on your business: from e-reputation to customer service, marketing or recruiting, the list could go on and on…

PROGRAMS

That is precisely what Brogan touched upon in the last part of this keynote, addressing the fact that different companies will use different programs to achieve their objectives, through the “home base – media empire – outposts” trilogy. Programs include but are not limited to: lead generation, content marketing, community engagement, sales, etc. For your business, it may include human resources (recruiting), public affairs, research & development, and so on.

CONCLUSION: Yes, in some very specific instances, and for some brands in given industries, social media can be a serious driver for sales, in particular using direct call-to-action tactics such as coupons or Facebook offers, for example. But sales is only one of the seven business drivers of a social media strategy and should be taken as such when looking at digital channels as a whole.


Frederic Gonzalo
Written by Frederic Gonzalo

Senior marketing and communications expert & speaker with 18 years expertise in the travel and hospitality industry. Consulting since early 2012, I provide strategic planning, social media & mobile development counseling to small and medium businesses alike. Reach me at frederic@gonzomarketing.biz

5 comments
Adi Gaskell
Adi Gaskell

For many social is a case of the emporer's new clothes.  So many people take the old rules of broadcast marketing and dump them onto social media.  It becomes a new way of getting your word out there to as many people as possible.  Sure people may use big data in smart ways to segment their audience or to listen to what's said on social networks and respond accordingly, but for many it remains a case of 'make and sell'.  This is what we make, do you want to buy it?

That for me kinda misses the point of social media, that it's a chance to engage so fully with your audience that they help make your products better, if not designing them themselves.  After all, the classic marketing orientation sees companies listening and fulfilling the needs they identify, not making stuff and then selling it anywhere they can.

Are Morch
Are Morch

Hi Frederic.

I had the opportunity to listen to Chris several times, also got some of his books. And often he focus on the points you make here that with Social Media we have to move ourselves out of the equation of selling. Or said in other terms Social Media is not about the Traditional Push (Marketing) and Pull (Sales). 

Social Media brings in new aspects like Share (Engagement) and Earn (Relationships), and the clue is to combine these new elements to build trust.  

The email list is almost like a store inside a mall. There can be thousands that get inside the mall, but you need an attractive glue that make your business stand out. And build trust with your customers, and find new creative ways to retain them. With you email list you have this opportunity.  

So even if we move our selves out of selling with Social Media, it is no way the same as you will not be provided an opportunity to sell your service and product. When it comes to the end of the day ROI is what all of us measure of results by. 

Cheers..

Are Morch

Hotel Blogger

gonzogonzo
gonzogonzo moderator

@Adi Gaskell I guess it's what we mean when we say social media represent a paradigm shift in how we communicate. It's easy to say... but much harder to grasp and embrace, as you point out. The unidirectional "push"-type of tactic has been around for so long that it's not so easy to let go, for many folks...

gonzogonzo
gonzogonzo moderator

@Are Morch Well said, Are. And that's perhaps the strongest point Chris made during his sessions when he mentioned he was selling more than 10x more via his email list than through other social media, or outposts. It was not to say social media don't sell per se, but they ought to be considered as part of a bigger plan, driving traffic towards home base (web site, call center, point of sale, etc.). And that's how brands will measure their ROI, in the end.

Adi Gaskell
Adi Gaskell

@gonzogonzo @Adi Gaskell And I suppose the folks in management positions now have grown up with that style of reporting.  Hard to teach an old dog new tricks.